Waverley Borough Council Committee System - Committee Document
Meeting of the Corporate Overview and Scrutiny Committee held on 23/01/2006
Revenue Estimates 2006/2007
Waverley Borough Council
CoRPORATE OVERVIEW AND SCRUTINY COMMITTEE – 23RD JANUARY 2006
FINANCIAL STRATEGY 2006/2007 – 2008/2009
DRAFT GENERAL FUND - REVENUE ESTIMATES 2006/2007
[Wards Affected: All]
Summary and purpose:
This report updates the Committee on the latest position regarding the General Fund Budget. It contains proposals for reducing the Budget shortfall, which the Executive considered on 10th January.
This Committee is asked to give its views on subsequent recommendations from the Executive. The Executive will give final consideration to the Budget on 7th February 2006, including the comments reported from the Overview and Scrutiny meetings, before making recommendations to Council on 21st February 2006.
There are no direct environmental implications as a result of the recommendation of this report. However, the estimates do include services that do have very significant environmental benefits.
There are no direct social/community implications as a result of the recommendation of this report. However, the estimates do include services that do have very significant social/community benefits.
The Estimates contain budgets to enable the delivery of Waverley’s E-Government Strategy.
Resource and legal implications:
There are no direct legal implications as a result of the recommendation of this report. Resource implications are contained throughout the report.
1. The draft 2005/2006 General Fund Revenue Estimates were presented to the Corporate Overview and Scrutiny Committee on 21st November 2005.
Members are requested to refer to the detailed Estimates contained at Annexes 1 and 2 to the Budget Item (Appendix C) for that meeting and to bring these papers to the meeting in January.
2. In order that information is available to the Committee as early as possible, this report is based on the suggestions made by the Chief Officer Group, as submitted for consideration by the Executive on 10th January. The recommendations from the Executive on 10th are set out at
which should be referred to when considering this report.
The Revenue Support Grant Settlement
3. As reported to the Executive on 6th December, Waverley’s provisional Revenue Support Grant Settlement for 2006/2007 was received earlier that day. The key figures and an updated Budget Summary was distributed at the Executive.
4. The details of the Settlement are:
The Settlement is for two years;
Waverley receives an additional 3% in Government Grant for 2006/07 and 2.7% for 2007/08;
Council Tax capping remains – The Government expects increases to be below 5% for 2006/07 and 2007/08;
A new system of allocating grant based on Relative Needs Formula has been introduced; and
Waverley is now £520,000 below the floor following this change.
The total cash increase for Waverley is £580,000. This amount includes approximately £400,000 to cover the cost of the introduction of free travel under the Concessionary Fare Scheme from 1st April 2006. Waverley’s share of the increased cost of the Surrey scheme is now estimated to b £390,000, so as intended the effect on Waverley is broadly neutral.
Planning Delivery Grant
5. For 2005/06 Waverley’s share of Planning Delivery Grant is £480,000, of which 25% has to be spent on capital items, with the remaining £360,000 covering revenue expenditure. Council has approved expenditure during 2005/06, which is covered by the grant of £360,000. This level of expenditure is included in the base budget for 2006/07 and likewise the existing level of grant was originally assumed. However, the main tranche of Waverley’s Planning Delivery Grant for 2006/07 has now been announced and Waverley’s share has reduced by £120,000 for revenue and by £40,000 for capital despite improved Planning Service performance.
6. The reduced figure has been included in the updated Budget Summary, thereby increasing the Budget shortfall by £120,000. Possible administration savings within the Planning Department are referred to elsewhere in this report. A detailed examination of Waverley’s Planning costs relative to other authorities is currently being carried out
7. The latest Budget position is shown on the Budget Summary at
Proposed Service Variations
8. The list of variations is attached at
gives an explanation from the Budget Officers for the request of variation item.
The Edge Sports Centre
9. A report has been presented to the Executive on 10th January detailing the contract review process, which is due for the Edge Sports Centre. The most likely outcome is an increase in cost to Waverley of £9,000 in 2006/2007. This has been treated as a late variation item and thereby taken into account in the updated Budget Summary.
Fees and Charges
10. Generally, increases in charges in line with delegated authority have been allowed for within the draft Estimates.
11. Revised Car Park charges to take effect from 1st February 2006 were agreed by Council on 13th December. Additional income generated for 2006/07 is estimated at £90,000 and is taken into account in the budget figures.
12. The Chief Officer Group considers that this year there is very limited scope to reduce the Budget shortfall by increasing fees and charges further in any areas.
Analysis of Shortfall
13. The following table provides an overview of how the shortfall of some £375,000, as reported to the Executive, has arisen:
Net Expenditure 2005/2006
Shortfall funded from Balances 2005/2006
Net Inflation items
Free Bus Travel for over 60s
Loss of Planning Delivery Grant
New Net Expenditure 2006/07 **
Revenue Support Grant (including increase to cover Free Bus Travel)
Council Tax (assuming 3% increase)
*Based on provisional Revenue Support Grant Settlement and on current pay offer.
**The Estimates will continue to be worked on. Any amendments will be reported to the Executive in February.
14. Officers have been advised that proposed changes to the superannuation scheme, which remove the 85 year rule and changes which allow for commutation of pension income for extra lump sum should secure savings that will offset potential additional costs arising from the deferral of the 85 year rule’s withdrawal. The next formal revaluation will be in April 2007 to take effect in the 2008/2009 Budget.
Further Potential Reductions
15. Following the Executive on 6th December, the Chief Officer Group commenced the process of examining the draft Budget for further possible reductions. The list of potential reductions is shown at
, together with an appraisal of the impact of these reductions at
. The list totals approximately £380,000.
16. However, within the list, the Chief Officer Group has identified £136,800 variation items where the service improvements are considered to justify fully an increase in council tax beyond 3%. The Chief Officer Group advise that the Executive should consider increasing council tax by 4.9%, which will generate an additional £140,000, rather than deleting these service improvements
Housing Benefit Subsidy
17. In 2004/05 the Government made changes to the Housing Benefit Subsidy system and began to reimburse Local Authorities effectively for 100% of their expenditure as a specific grant, rather than in part through the Revenue Support Grant.
18. However, subsidy claims are made on the basis of the gross expenditure in the benefits system, which can differ substantially from the amount passed to the financial accounts as this excludes overpayments.
19. It is therefore possible for subsidy recovered to amount to more than 100% of the cost shown in the financial accounts. This has proved to be the case in 2004/05, the first year of the new system, for which the Audit Commission is just about to sign-off Waverley’s subsidy claim.
20. The volume of Housing Benefits paid by Waverley is extremely large and so even a very low change in the effective subsidy rate can result in a substantial net amount.
21. For technical reasons in the first year of the new system there was a greater impact and in 2004-2005 prior-year adjustments are some £300,000.
22. However, it does seem that there is likely to be an ongoing revenue effect, which could result in a saving in the region of £200,000 from the figures currently included within the draft Budget. A definitive sum will be reported to the Executive in February.
23. The reductions suggested by the Chief Officer Group will achieve the reported shortfall figure of £375,000. If further close examination confirms that it will be reasonable to budget for increased subsidy on Housing Benefits, it will be possible to consider making a revenue contribution in 2006/2007 towards financing the capital programme; or to take a more sustainable approach by reducing or removing the contribution of £250,000 from the Revenue Reserve Fund thus enabling the capital funding from the Revenue Reserve Fund to increase.
24. If the £250,000 contribution to General Fund Revenue is removed and the Chief Officer Group recommendations for reductions are accepted, this will leave a shortfall of £44,000 on the General Fund Revenue Account and reduce the shortfall on the Capital Programme to £336,000. These figures may be regarded as realistic targets for achievement at this stage of the Budget process.
25. The Overview and Scrutiny Committees are giving consideration to the Budget at their meetings in January and any comments made will be reported to the meeting of the Executive on 7th February 2006, which will agree final recommendations to Council on 21st February 2006.
It is recommended that the Committee give further consideration to the draft General Fund Estimates for 2006/2007, including the proposed Budget Reductions.
Provisional Local Government Finance Settlement 2006/07; Financial Strategy 2006/07 – 2008/09; Finance Seminar slides; draft Service Plans 2006/07; Community Strategy; Revenue Budget 2005/06.